Yes I agree but Chuck was a two time All American.
So were Caveness and Phillips. Phillips also won the Outland Trophy. Caveness held every Arkansas tackling record when he graduated and still holds some of them now. The man was a tackling machine.
Dicus, Caveness, and Phillips are all members of the College Football Hall of Fame so you couldn't really go wrong picking any of them. Dicus was fantastic, and the bigger the game the bigger he played. He dominated the Sugar Bowl win over Georgia and was unstoppable against Texas in the Big Shootout.