3 Worst and 3 Best SEC Football Coaches

[Hoggie17]

The 3 Worst:

1.  Bret Bielema
2.  Butch Jones
3.  Derek Mason

The 3 Best:

1.  Nick   Saban
2.  Gus Malzahn
3.  Kirby Smart

[Hoggie17]

Kirby is in  his first year but I added him because of what he has done for Ga and his record at Ala.

[TX HOG]

Mullen

[Hoggie17]

Mullen

It was a hard choice between Mullen and Smart.  Mullen does do more with less.

[Sow’sEar]

This is Kirby Smart's second year...

[Hoggish1]

Kirby is in  his first SECOND year[/s][/s]  but I added him because of what he has done for Ga and his record at Ala.

But OK, carry on...

[BR]

The 3 Worst:

1.  Bret Bielema
2.  Butch Jones
3.  Derek Mason

The 3 Best:

1.  Nick   Saban
2A. Dan Mullen
2B.  Gus Malzahn
3.  Kirby Smart

[IronMountainHog]

When I post stuff like this, even when relevant, the Mods move it to SEC sports or some other forum no one reads.

[BearsBisonsBoars]

The 3 Worst:

1.  Bret Bielema
2.  Butch Jones
3.  Derek Mason

The 3 Best:

1.  Nick   Saban
2.  Gus Malzahn
3.  Kirby Smart

Mason does not belong in the worst. Odom probably should take that spot, but really all the middle of the road coaches are about the same imo.

Gus in the top three is laughable and probably agenda driven. Especially with Mullen left out.


Also, Butch is much worse than Bret. That's not saying much, but he may be the worst multiple year SEC coach I've seen, all things considered.

[LRRandy]

Mason does not belong in the worst. Odom probably should take that spot, but really all the middle of the road coaches are about the same imo.

Gus in the top three is laughable and probably agenda driven. Especially with Mullen left out.

you kinda gotta give Odom credit for the improvement Mizzou has shown. They are going bowling after looking like one of the worst teams in the country after 4 games.

[BearsBisonsBoars]

you kinda gotta give Odom credit for the improvement Mizzou has shown. They are going bowling after looking like one of the worst teams in the country after 4 games.

I'll give him credit for getting out of his coordinators ways. But what does he bring to the table himself?

Besides, the bulk of that improvement has been against ooc cupcakes and Butch Jones, and freshly coachless Florida.

[LRRandy]

Worst. Bielema, Luke, Jones

Best. Saban, Mullen, Malzahn

[ChicoHog]

you kinda gotta give Odom credit for the improvement Mizzou has shown. They are going bowling after looking like one of the worst teams in the country after 4 games.

No kidding.  I thought they end up 3-9 at best after the first few games.  They have really found themselves. 

Best:
1.  Saban
2.  Mullen
3.  No one stands out although Smart and even Muschamp are on their way. 

Worst
1.  Jones
2.  Bielema
3.  The rest of them.

[LRRandy]

I'll give hime credit for getting out of his coordinators ways. But what does he bring to the table himself?

he is the head coach of a team that has shown remarkable improvement. I admittedly don't know enough about him or the program to dive deep on what he brings to the table. I do know that if they had continued on the course they set early in the season,  he would have been fired.

[BearsBisonsBoars]

As i see it, in order of goodness.

Saban tier:
Saban

Good tier:
Mullen
Smart

Passable tier:
Champ (suprisingly)
O
Malzhan
Sumlin
Stoops
Mason

Bad tier:
The dude at Ole Mrs   
Odom
The dude at Florida

Embarrassment tier:
Bret
Jones

There not much gap between passable and bad, imo

[Pecos Hog]

As i see it, in order of goodness.

Saban tier:
Saban

Good tier:
Mullen
Smart

Passable tier:
Champ (suprisingly)
O
Malzhan
Sumlin
Stoops
Mason

Bad tier:
The dude at Ole Mrs   
Odom
The dude at Florida

Embarrassment tier:
Bret
Jones

There not much gap between passable and bad, imo

Yeah, might as well rank em all.    More fun that way.

[GunnerHawg70]

As i see it, in order of goodness.

Saban tier:
Saban

Good tier:
Mullen
Smart

Passable tier:
Champ (suprisingly)
O
Malzhan
Sumlin
Stoops
Mason

Bad tier:
The dude at Ole Mrs   
Odom
The dude at Florida - Randy should've stayed at Arkansas!!!

Embarrassment tier:
Bret
Jones

There not much gap between passable and bad, imo

Pretty much spot on...Bravo!!!👏🏽